Easy Dinner Idea – 20 Minute Mini Spaghetti Pie Recipe

Does your family have that one recipe that they always end up turning to in a dinner crunch, or when you just can’t think of what the heck to make for dinner?  For our family, that is our spaghetti sauce (why I haven’t written a better post for this yet, I’m not sure… but be sure to keep your eyes peeled for it, it’s coming!).  When DJ and I first started dating, he made me pasta one night, and I’m pretty sure that this pasta is what sealed the deal, and when I really fell in love.  Blah, blah blah… you can read more about that here.

Last week, I posted a recipe for Homemade Spaghetti and Meatballs for National Spaghetti Day.  After celebrating at home, I had a lot of extra spaghetti left.  If you have been following Mom’s Bistro for a while, you know that I’m kind of obsessed with The Sopranos, and there was a recipe for Spaghetti Pie in one of The Sopranos cookbooks.  The recipe in the cookbook calls for prosciutto and pancetta, and I can’t eat pork, so I used the recipe as more of a guide, and came up with a kid-friendly version for these mini spaghetti pies.

30-Minute Kid-Friendly Mini Spaghetti Pie Recipe
30-Minute Kid-Friendly Mini Spaghetti Pie Recipe

These mini spaghetti pies are super cute and really fun to eat.  Your kids will love the fact that they get their very own spaghetti pie.  Around here, we call individual-size foods or mini-sized foods ‘Anthony Size’, but you could even serve these as an appetizer at a party – just use the mini-cupcake tins instead!).  It might seem like a long process to make, but you can prepare everything you need while the spaghetti cooks (if your not using leftover spaghetti), and the oven preheats.

Making these mini spaghetti pies is easy, and even if you have to cook the pasta, they are ready in 30 minutes.  A perfect weeknight meal that everyone will love.

mini spaghetti pie recipe

Yields:  18 cupcake-size mini spaghetti pies (or one deep pie plate)

Gather your ingredients: (I made a double batch in the pictures)

For Spaghetti Crust:
1, 12 oz box spaghetti
3 eggs
1/4 cup parmesan cheese

1-2 cups crockpot spaghetti sauce – make it over the weekend, and keep it in your fridge or freezer, you’ll use it.  Believe me!

For “Pot Cheese”:
1, 15oz ricotta cheese
2 cups mozzarella cheese, divided
1/2 cup grated parmesan cheese
1 tbsp fresh basil, optional
1 egg
salt and pepper

olive oil, to prepare muffin tins

Preheat your oven to 375 degrees.

In a large bowl, mix 1 1/2 cups mozzarella cheese, ricotta cheese, parmesan cheese, eggs, salt, pepper and basil.

pot cheese
Pot Cheese – Use this same recipe for baked ziti, lasagna or stuffed shells!

Meanwhile, cook pasta according to package directions until al dente – about 10 minutes.  Drain and toss with 1 tbsp olive oil, and set aside to cool. DO NOT RINSE YOUR PASTA!

Cooked Spaghetti

Lightly coat 2 muffin tins with oil and set aside until spaghetti is cooled a little.

Once your spaghetti is cooled, grab a small bunch – it’s hard to say how much in a measurement, and place in your prepared muffin tin.

mini spaghetti pie step 3

It’s hard to tell in the pictures, so I tried to take one up close, but when you add the spaghetti to your muffin tins, make a little well in the middle.  This is where your filling will go.

mini spaghetti pie well spaghetti
Use your fingers to kind of swirl the spaghetti around the muffin tin to form a well.

Scoop 1-2 tbsp of pot cheese into each well that you created in the spaghetti.

ricotta and spaghetti

Then top each mini spaghetti pie with a spoonful of crockpot spaghetti sauce.

mini spaghetti pie


Top the pies with shredded mozzarella cheese.

mini spaghetti pie

Bake for 10-15 minutes or until the cheese is bubbly and brown, and the noodles are firm.  You can test this by running a butter knife along the side of the muffin tin, if it slides nice, and doesn’t feel mushy, your pies are ready.

baked mini spaghetti pie
They don’t look very pretty in the muffin tin, but BURST with flavor when you bite into them

Let cool 5 minutes.

Using an offset spatula or a butter knife, carefully remove mini spaghetti pies from muffin tins, and serve!

30-Minute Kid-Friendly Mini Spaghetti Pie Recipe
30-Minute Kid-Friendly Mini Spaghetti Pie Recipe

mini spaghetti pie

They tasted great reheated, so bring them for lunch or eat as a late night snack. These mini spaghetti pies are also great for a quick freezer meal – once cooled, throw your mini spaghetti pies on a sheet tray in a single layer and place in the freezer for 2-4 hours and then transfer to a labelled ziplock bag. Since they are small, they reheat in no time at all.

This was a great alternative to our regular spaghetti night, and Anthony absolutely loved that he had his very own pie, just like Daddy!

Love spaghetti?  Try one of these recipes!

Related Posts

Grandma’s Spaghetti Sauce | Crockpot Spaghetti Sauce Recipe

Grandma’s Spaghetti Sauce | Crockpot Spaghetti Sauce Recipe

I love this recipe.  I cook it at least once a week, and it was the first thing that D.J. made for me when we started dating.  I always knew that I’d marry an Italian boy, but this recipe really sealed the deal.  There is […]

Ultimate Kid Approved Menu – Kid Friendly Meals – A Week of Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner & Snack Ideas

Ultimate Kid Approved Menu – Kid Friendly Meals – A Week of Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner & Snack Ideas

These recipes are my most-loved by the kids at my school.  There are a ton of opportunities to add more veggies to your kids diet in the meals that they love the most!  What is your kids favorite meal?   Want more kid-approved meals?  Scroll […]

8 thoughts on “Easy Dinner Idea – 20 Minute Mini Spaghetti Pie Recipe”

  • I am so excited to use your recipes this month for my meal plans. I have been planning meals for a long time, but I have never planned an entire month! I thought I would try your August plan to begin with, and see how it goes!

    I had a question about this recipe, though. At the top, it says you add 3 eggs and Parmesan cheese to the spaghetti crust, but I didn’t see it in the directions that follow. Do you add it to the spaghetti after it cools off and before you put it in the muffin pan?

    Thank you for posting your recipes and equipping moms to feed their families on a budget. I can’t wait to share my thoughts after the month is over. You’ve been a lifesaver!

    • Hi Lauren!

      Whhoops! Writing recipes can be hard sometimes! Add the eggs to the spaghetti when you’re making the “crust” before you add them to the muffin tins – it might be a little sticky in your hands, but will make it easier to make!

      Hope this helps!

      Lindsie 🙂

  • Lindsie,
    Loving this planning for a month thing! Just wondering if you have an area where just the recipe can be printed without the pics?

    • Hey Krista!

      I am slowly working on this and am hoping by the end of September all of the recipes will be done! I don’t know why I didn’t add a printable recipe from the beginning, but I guess we live and learn!

  • Our supper planning has become much easier since finding your site and this mini spaghetti pie recipe is now a regular in our rotation. Thank you for all your hard work!

    Robin (Canuck Mum)

Leave a Reply: